Customer Reviews
What People Are Saying
Real feedback from real customers. We're grateful for every review and strive to make each loaf better than the last.
Featured Reviews
“I HAD to send this crumb shot!!! Holy smokes, it is DELICIOUS! Even my mom (who doesn't like sourdough) loved it! I will DEF be ordering more!”
Ashley
Plain Sourdough Loaf
“We bought a loaf of Chocolate Strawberry Sourdough from Sara's here in Collingswood for Valentine's and are going back tomorrow in hopes of finding another just like it. It's exceptional; the chocolate and strawberry laced tastefully inside so that sliced and toasted, served with a glass of wine was the best part of our celebration.”
Nelson Denbigh
Collingswood, NJ|Chocolate Strawberry Sourdough Loaf
More Reviews
“Enjoying my first loaf right now. YUM!!! Thank you Tyler 💚🙌🏽🍃 MAGNIFICENT!!!”
Roxanne
Jalapeño Cheddar Sourdough Loaf
“The pictures speak for themselves, you have to try this.”
Frankie Ranzino
Pepperoni Mozzarella Sourdough Loaf
“I picked up some loaves last night, Rosemary and regular sourdough. Eating Rosemary now and it is delicious. Sorry Wegmans, I'll be going to Blackwood more”
Shannon S
Custom Request Sourdough Loaf
“It's been awesome! We did a couple test loafs to figure stuff out, then my wife made this one”
Yusdel
Active Sourdough Starter
“Very good. I'm camping in the snow in the Delaware Water Gap and we just had them with goat curry. Really good.”
John
Custom Request Sourdough Loaf
“It was fantastic! I'll be ordering another next week! You have a gift!!”
Donna
Plain Sourdough Loaf
“Tyler was really responsive. Asked him for a custom loaf: blueberry white chocolate chip and it was incredible. Very fun that he's willing to experiment and make pretty much whatever you ask. Looking forward to eventually trying the jalapeño cheddar, alongside other fun combinations.”
Brian
Custom Request Sourdough Loaf
“Sour dough bread is amazing and Tyler was great and very accommodating. Thank you!”
Sandy
Plain Sourdough Loaf
“I bought a loaf Custom with cheese and pepperoni. When he hand it to me it was huge and still warm right out of the oven. He was very prompt. He's an excellent baker and I'm picking up another one today. He has no problem accommodating your special request. I can't say enough good things about him”
Dennis
Atco, NJ|Pepperoni Mozzarella Sourdough Loaf
“So informative, and helpful”
Gi
Active Sourdough Starter
“Hands down the best sourdough loaf I’ve ever had. I will 100% be ordering it again.”
Caitlin
Roasted Garlic
“Solid sourdough. Perfect crust, really good flavor. I’m ordering again.”
Mike
Plain Sourdough
Mantis
Active Sourdough Starter
Bella
Sourdough Starter
Tried our bread?
We'd love to hear from you! Share your experience and photos.